Published by Hitched 2 Homicide | True Crime Podcast "The jury got this wrong. It's completely the opposite of what it should be. My client should have received at most an eight-year sentence, and Mr. Mundt should be sitting in prison right now on a potential life sentence." — Darren Wolff, defense attorney for Joey Banis Previously, in Old Louisville... If you haven't read Part One yet, go back and start there — because the story you're about to read only hits as hard as it

This is the story of James "Jamie" Carroll — hairdresser, drag queen, meth dealer, and a man whose magnetic personality made everyone in the room feel like the most important person alive. It is also the story of Jeffrey "Jase" Mundt and Joseph "Joey" Banis — two men bound together by drugs, obsession, and secrets so dark that even the city's beloved Victorian shadows couldn't keep them buried forever.

*This case deals with domestic violence. Viewer and listener discretion is advised. If you or someone you know needs help, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 800-799-7233 (SAFE), or text START to 88788. You can also chat at hotline.org Last updated: Feb. 17, 2026 | Important note: Suzanne’s body has not been publicly confirmed as recovered. Brad Simpson has pleaded not guilty in court proceedings reported by multiple outlets, and he is presumed innocent unless an

In 1981, a quiet Connecticut town became the stage for a legal gambit unlike anything in U.S. courts. When Arne Cheyenne Johnson’s case collided with the Glatzel family’s reports of “possession,” the Warrens, and multiple clergy, headlines erupted. This Hitched 2 Homicide episode rebuilds the timeline, explains why the claim was barred, and explores a grounded alternative. Was David Glatzel possessed by a demon?

The Lindbergh Kidnapping: What We Know, What We Still Debate. On the night of March 1, 1932, America’s most famous family suffered its...

The Lindbergh Kidnapping: What We Know, What We Still Debate. On the night of March 1, 1932, America’s most famous family suffered its...

Lizzie Borden: The Axe Murder That Still Haunts Fall River On the morning of August 4, 1892, the quiet town of Fall River, Massachusetts, became the backdrop for one of the most infamous unsolved murders in American history. Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally hacked to death in their own home, their skulls shattered by multiple blows from a hatchet. Suspicion quickly fell on Andrew’s youngest daughter, Lizzie Borden—a respectable, church-going woman whose name would b

Lizzie Borden: The Axe Murder That Still Haunts Fall River On the morning of August 4, 1892, the quiet town of Fall River, Massachusetts, became the backdrop for one of the most infamous unsolved murders in American history. Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally hacked to death in their own home, their skulls shattered by multiple blows from a hatchet. Suspicion quickly fell on Andrew’s youngest daughter, Lizzie Borden—a respectable, church-going woman whose name would b

The Deadly Affair: The Laura Safford Miller Case In the winter of 1950, a dramatic and tragic tale of love, betrayal, and death unfolded...

The Jane Anker Hylton Case: A Tale of Justice, Injustice, and DNA Exoneration In the quiet suburb of Sacramento, California, on a fateful...

The Tragic Coleman Family Murders: A True Crime Story The Morning of May 5th, 2009: A Community Shattered In a quiet neighborhood near...

October 16, 1931, Phoenix Arizona, Winnie Ruth Judd is visiting her two best friends, Anne and Sammy at their small bungalow—they’d been...

December 30th 1610. A powerful member of the Báthory clan of Transylvania is arrested after allegedly being found soaked in blood while...

June 18, 1977, Tucson, Arizona. 39 -year-old Chuck Morgan is found lying near his new car, 40 miles west of his home—11 days after he...

May 10, 2019. It’s Mother’s Day, and mom Suzanne Morphew is home while her husband Barry is an hour and a half away on a job site. When...

June 27, 1977 Elisabeth Congdon, heir to a copper and iron ore fortune is murdered in the family mansion in Duluth, Minnesota. Also...

June 13, 1980. Allan Gore is leaving his Texas home, his wife Betty and two daughters for a business trip in Minnesota. While he's gone,...

September 5th, Labor Day weekend, 1921. Silent movie star and comedian Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle is in San Francisco with his buddies for a...

April 26, 1895, Little Italy, New York, New York. Maria Barbella, a twenty-two year old Italian immigrant who worked in a sweatshop, is...

April 4, 1958, Oscar nominated actress Lana Turner is fighting with her boyfriend—a man with known connections to the mob. In the house,...